Pacifiers are a great benefit for parents as they aid in the oral development of toddlers, improve their sleeping habits, and provide them with a calming sensation. They come in multiple designs, colors, features, and shapes. 

There’s no denying the viability of a pacifier, but the sheer abundance of these in the market — and almost all by different brands — has made it crucial to turn selective when looking for the best pacifier for breastfed babies.

Finding the best pacifiers for breastfed babies isn’t an easy task. Luckily for you, we’ve done the work for you and have come up with this list of top pacifiers suitable during naps, play, and bedtime. Let’s get started!

Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies: Reviews

1. Chicco PhysioForma Pacifier

PhysioForma Orthodontic Silicone Pacifier is a one-piece product that offers orthodontic and breathing benefits to babies. It comes with ventilation holes that support physiological breathing and proper air circulation, thereby improving the sleep quality of your little one. Plus, there are no chances of moisture buildup on their skin.

Its exclusive design features a lateral curve, tiny ridges, and a slim and inclined nipple shape that distributes the baby’s tongue pressure evenly across their palate. Special attention must be given to the unique angle of the nipple, which is crafted with care to ensure proper and comfortable tongue placement. Overall, it supports the baby’s growing teeth and palate.

The design for this product was developed under the guidance of expert orthodontists, pediatricians, and neonatologists. Also, the PhysioForma has strictly followed the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines, so rest assured that it’s a baby-friendly product.


  • Brand: Chicco
  • Product Dimensions: 2.5 x 2 x 1.7 inches
  • Item Weight: 2.46 ounces
  • Material Type: 100% Silicone

View on Amazon


2. MAM Night Pacifier

Are you tired of dealing with the frustration of finding your baby’s “lost” pacifier in the dark? In that case, the MAM Night Pacifier is for you. It glows at night, making it easy for both the parent and baby to locate it. In addition, these Night Pacifiers are made using BPA-free silicone by expert pediatric psychologists and dentists.

Suitable for 0-6 month babies, the pacifier’s curved shield design includes air holes and provides room for the baby’s dimples and nose. Next, the opening in the curved shield allows air circulation, keeping the baby’s skin healthy and moisture-free.

The innovative nipple design of the MAM pacifiers features an anti-slip texture, meaning it fits into the baby’s mouth comfortably. Plus, it also promotes healthy teeth and gum development in toddlers. The pacifier’s nipple comes with a built-in air channel that flattens and extends naturally when sucked, giving comfort and feel to the baby that otherwise only breastfeeding could.


  • Brand: MAM
  • Product Dimensions: 6.5 x 3.5 x 2.5 inches
  • Item Weight: 1.13 ounces
  • Material Type: Silicone

View on Amazon


3. Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier

Itzy Ritzy has made for you an excellent soother pacifier for your newborn. That said, it’s also suitable for babies in their early stages of teeth development. Its one-piece design comes with a collapsible braided handle and nipple made of latex-free, soft silicone. 

You’ll find two large vent holes for easy breathability and added safety. The pacifier clip can be secured to its handle instead of the air hole. Both the size and the design of this product are flawless. 

You’ll get two pacifiers in one purchase, making it one of the most cost-effective pacifiers out there. Also, you won’t have to deal with the hassle of storing the pacifiers as they come with a protective pod making them easy to carry in a diaper bag when traveling.

The pacifiers are available in a wide selection of beautiful contrasting color combinations. These pacifiers are free of BPA and PVC. They can be cleaned and sterilized in the dishwasher (top rack only). A microwave steam sterilizer bag is a good alternative for sterilization. All in all, the product is a complete package and has everything you’d want in a safe and comfortable pacifier. 


  • Brand: Itzy Ritzy
  • Product Dimensions: 2 x 2 x 2.35 inches
  • Item Weight: 0.64 ounces
  • Material Type: Silicone

View on Amazon


4. Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier

The Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier has natural flex and feel, perhaps because it’s created with a soft and fully reversible silicone baglet. There’s no “correct side” in this pacifier, so you won’t have to worry about its correct placement in the baby’s mouth. Instead, it features a unique symmetrical design that keeps its curves away from the delicate skin of your little one. In addition, the holes added towards the nipple offer excellent airflow and ventilation while preventing rashes. 

The best part is that it doesn’t disrupt the bottle or breastfeeding. Also, this BPA-free pacifier is dishwasher safe. That said, feel free to clean and wash it by hand or in a sterilizer. 

The breast-like pacifier is perfect for newborns and 6 to 10-month-old babies. The size available for 0-6 month babies has a small shield and nipple for tiny noses and mouths. The Tommee Tippee pacifier for 6-18-month-olds offers similar benefits but features a comparatively larger shield and nipple.


  • Brand: Tommee Tippee
  • Product Dimensions: 2.36 x 4.33 x 4.92 inches
  • Item Weight: 1.44 ounces
  • Material Type: Silicone

View on Amazon


5. Philips AVENT Soothie Heart Pacifier

This product from Philips Avent for calming newborns is backed by medical experts. Suitable for 3-18-month-old babies, this heart-shaped pacifier features a curved shield for extra comfort to your baby. 

It’s made of latex and hospital-grade silicone that adds to the product’s durability and strength. Like the Chicco PhysioForma Pacifier, it’s a one-piece product. It’s shaped and sized carefully to fit comfortably in the baby’s mouth.

Most importantly, the company has adhered to all the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines as far as designing and manufacturing are concerned. 

It aids in the normal oral development of babies and has smooth, firm, odorless, and transparent nipples. To top that off, it won’t become too sticky, nor are there any chances of discoloration. 

It’s a perfect solution for busy parents who look for easy and quick pacifier sterilizing solutions. The product is dishwasher safe and BPA-free. Alternatively, you can sterilize it using a Philips Avent sterilizer. 

A standout feature of this product is its unique design that’ll let you help your baby with suckling by placing their fingers in the product. Lastly, it’s suitable for the smooth development and growth of babies’ teeth, gums, and palates.


  • Brand: Philips AVENT
  • Product Dimensions: 5.43 x 3.62 x 1.42 inches
  • Item Weight: 1.44 ounces
  • Material Type: Silicone

View on Amazon


Tips to Buy The Right Pacifier for Your Baby

Are you still confused about which is the best pacifier for your baby? It’s best to break it down and decide based on what your baby needs. Consider the following aspects when making this very important decision:


Pacifiers are made either of latex, rubber, or silicone. That said, the best ones are usually the silicone ones since some babies may develop an allergy to latex and rubber being rubber, may break down comparatively faster. 

Silicone pacifiers are dishwasher safe and transparent, whereas rubber and latex pacifiers are opaque. 


The classic rounded pacifiers would be your best bet since they’re recommended by orthodontics. However, feel free to go for the ones with unique shapes but make sure to invest some time in researching and finding the right shape that fits comfortably in your baby’s mouth. 

Some pacifiers have shapes similar to bottle nipples, while some are designed specifically for breastfed babies. Avoid buying pacifiers that don’t have a sufficient number of air holes.

Shape and Size

The shape and size of the pacifier should match the shape and size of your little one’s mouth contour. Pick the one that perfectly complements your baby’s age. If need be, take a pediatrician’s help to find the right product. Replace the product with a bigger size as your baby grows.


The safest pacifiers come in one piece. Also, go for the ones that feature ventilated and large-sized face shields. 


Pacifiers are usually reasonably priced but the price tags vary based on quality and brand. We suggest you don’t get lured by the unique and pompous features of different available pacifiers. Buy the one that functions properly for your baby and suits their needs. 

Why Choose Silicone Over Latex When Buying Pacifiers?

Silicone is firmer than latex, meaning pacifiers made of silicone are long-lasting and sturdy. They don’t break down quickly, unlike latex pacifiers. Also, some babies are allergic to latex, though this is rare.

That said, silicone may not be a suitable option for parents who prefer using a natural material. Also, it’s a synthetic material and chemically treated, whereas latex is naturally sourced from trees. 

Additional Pacifier Handling Tips 

  • Keep them sterilized and clean: Boil the pacifiers as part of the sterilization process. Alternatively, you may wash them in the dishwasher.
  • Don’t use them for replacing or delaying meals: Pediatricians recommend pacifiers only for soothing or relaxing the baby’s mouth. They aren’t meant for meal replacement.
  • Keep them in a secure, clean, and safe place: Pacifiers shouldn’t be left in your baby’s crib. Also, avoid tying it to their hands or feet as it may get dirty or damaged.


So that was all about the best pacifiers for breastfed babies. In case you’re struggling to zero in on the perfect option for your baby, here’s a short review of all our products to make the selection easy for you:

  • Chicco PhysioForma Pacifier is our #1 recommendation. It features a contoured shield with an adequate number of holes for air circulation. There’s also an inclined and soft nipple for unparalleled comfort of your baby.
  • If you want a pacifier that’s easy to locate in the dark and comes with a sterilizing storage case, pick the MAM Night Pacifier. Its BPA-free, silicone nipple will help in the teeth and jaw development of your baby. 
  • Go for the Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier if you’re looking for a value for money proposition — you get two units in one purchase. It also has all the features of a high-quality pacifier, such as a collapsible braided handle, large air holes, and a protective pod. 
  • The symmetrical design and shape of the Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier differentiate it from the others on the list. Its BPA-free silicone build will keep odors and stains at bay. 
  • Philips AVENT Soothie Heart Pacifier will be the perfect buy if you need a BPA-free pacifier that’s also dishwasher safe and easy to sterilize. Its compatibility with multiple pacifier clips makes it one of the most highly recommended pacifiers.


A pacifier is a must if you want your toddler to have perfect oral health. Read our guide if you're looking for the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

You may also like

2022 Best strollers

2022 Best strollers

New Born Must-Haves

New Born Must-Haves
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Get in touch

0 of 350